Start of day - 12:30
Prestige dies - 2:05
@The Silver Shroud Was Prestige able to post/perform any actions/abilities he may have had during that time?
The Jason Bourne Mafia Game
- Thread starter The Silver Shroud
- Start date
Start of day - 12:30
Prestige dies - 2:05
@The Silver Shroud Was Prestige able to post/perform any actions/abilities he may have had during that time?
I went back through the thread and only myself, Drixx and Zemaj have claimed anything.
In light of this, its pretty much coming down to claim your side and victory condition specifically or you're getting lynched in some whimsical order.
Research time:
List of Characters - Notably listed are Jacob and Lev Silver (brothers)
Luthur LaValle - (Prestige)
Jason Bourne: this passage looks familiar..
Prestige's death makes me wonder if this game is actually Bourne vs Town+Mafia? It sounded to me like Prestige perhaps targeted Bourne, and he is some sort of Paranoid Gun Owner that kills anybody that visits him? I know from the movies at least, anybody that went after Bourne usually ended up dead..
@zemaj - I guess I should be less helpful? Being unhelpful is not PT. I read that somewhere..
List of Characters - Notably listed are Jacob and Lev Silver (brothers)
Luthur LaValle - (Prestige)
Jason Bourne: this passage looks familiar..
Prestige's death makes me wonder if this game is actually Bourne vs Town+Mafia? It sounded to me like Prestige perhaps targeted Bourne, and he is some sort of Paranoid Gun Owner that kills anybody that visits him? I know from the movies at least, anybody that went after Bourne usually ended up dead..
@zemaj - I guess I should be less helpful? Being unhelpful is not PT. I read that somewhere..
Hey guys.
Sigh, sorry, this game came at a really bad time for me.
I'll catch up now and give my thoughts.
No one died again at night? How is that possible that no one died two nights in a row? Especially now that we know Noodle was Town Doctor.
Sigh, sorry, this game came at a really bad time for me.
I'll catch up now and give my thoughts.
No one died again at night? How is that possible that no one died two nights in a row? Especially now that we know Noodle was Town Doctor.
"6) Every player gets one lynch vote during the day. Votes and unvotes need to be bolded . If your unvote isn't bold, it doesn't count. As long as Ican read it and figure out ho you are voting for, I will count the vote. Obviously names that are grossly misspelled will not be counted. I'm also not going to take issue with names being case sensitive."
So does this mean I can only cast a vote once, and that's it? The part about unvoting makes me unsure of this. Can I change my vote around?
So does this mean I can only cast a vote once, and that's it? The part about unvoting makes me unsure of this. Can I change my vote around?
Wow, okay, Prestige is a dead mafia according to OP's - and he died during DAY while attempting a NK? WTF
Welcome to the world of the living, Thingyman. As someone still relatively new to this group, I'd like to hear your take on Drixx's lie detector claim.
Three sir, three!
There have been three night phases so far.
Naah, that's just general boiler plate. Vote and unvote all you like. The one real caveat is that you must unvote before placing a new vote.
Three sir, three!
There have been three night phases so far.
Naah, that's just general boiler plate. Vote and unvote all you like. The one real caveat is that you must unvote before placing a new vote.
Now that someone has died the game can actually begin. It's been boring up until this point first few day phases are always a slog.
Digging through Prestige's post history, looking for connections.
Day one not much is posted of relevance. Places a couple joke votes:
To which the only person to really respond to it is Leo:
Later, D2 asks his "Name a townie" question, to which Prestige sidesteps quite wonderfully:
D2 calls him out on it, unvoting kestegs three hours before end of day to place the first vote on Prestige. Note that kestegs already had two votes on him, and was the only real option for a lynch on day one. D2 decides to remove the third vote (of five needed) to instead start a new train that has no chance of success.
Bonus points, this is also the post where D2 suggests that he knows how many mafia members there are.
Day Two analysis next post, I'll try to split them up for ease of reading.
Digging through Prestige's post history, looking for connections.
Day one not much is posted of relevance. Places a couple joke votes:
To which the only person to really respond to it is Leo:
Didn't know Tom Cruise was in this game!!!
It's scummy to post non-substantive. It's scummy to post substantively (is that a word?). It's scummy to use toilet paper the wrong way. You know what? We are all dirty and we need to wash our butts.
Later, D2 asks his "Name a townie" question, to which Prestige sidesteps quite wonderfully:
D2 calls him out on it, unvoting kestegs three hours before end of day to place the first vote on Prestige. Note that kestegs already had two votes on him, and was the only real option for a lynch on day one. D2 decides to remove the third vote (of five needed) to instead start a new train that has no chance of success.
Bonus points, this is also the post where D2 suggests that he knows how many mafia members there are.
Day Two analysis next post, I'll try to split them up for ease of reading.
@Mr_Thingyman :
As others have said, you may vote (and change your vote) as often as you like. As long as you properly unvote your last vote.
As others have said, you may vote (and change your vote) as often as you like. As long as you properly unvote your last vote.
Day two:
After a couple people ask D2 to clarify his statements about the mafia numbe
Kestegs moves his vote to Prestige:
Which shortly afterwards Prestige responds to kestegs, talking about D2's 'who is town?' question:
Which then causes kestegs to immediately remove his vote from Prestige and switch over to D2:
I prod him about something he said that didn't quite sound right to me:
To which I get this non-answer:
And then he dies.
Analysis next.
After a couple people ask D2 to clarify his statements about the mafia numbe
Kestegs moves his vote to Prestige:
Which shortly afterwards Prestige responds to kestegs, talking about D2's 'who is town?' question:
Which then causes kestegs to immediately remove his vote from Prestige and switch over to D2:
I prod him about something he said that didn't quite sound right to me:
To which I get this non-answer:
And then he dies.
Analysis next.
Looks like a couple parts of my two above posts got lost in formatting, probably because I'm bouncing back and forth between pages and the draft saves of my replies weren't keeping up. Think the gist is kept well enough; let me know if something doesn't make sense and I'll try to clarify.
To me, Prestige's actions on Day One and Day Two look like standard mafia behaviour. Tentative to post, but quick to respond when a safe topic is presented or someone interacts with him directly. Typical "don't want to make waves" type of behaviour. Feels safer approaching conversation with his scum buddies (more on the plurality in a second), doesn't interact with those not on his team (I.E., town) unless they approach him first.
Then there is this post:
Scenario one: Both scum.
Scenario two: Zarni scum, Drixx town.
Scenario three: Zarni town, Drixx scum.
Where is scenario four, where both are town? This screams to me like mafia member trying to set up a lynch train on two people he knows will both flip town.
His move of day one vote helps prevent the lynching of his partner, but still allows him to keep a vote on a mafia partner should he later be flipped and revealed scum. His day two vote stays on Zarniwoop the entire day, even though he fingers kestegs and prestige as his two highest scum reads. These are the actions of someone who, when his partners flip, can reach back and say "Hey, I thought he was scum this entire time!", but doesn't want to actively help in their demise.
I'm of the opinion that D2DC and kestegs are partners amd Prestige was on their team.
Vote: DiabloTwoinDC
I could also be persuaded to move my vote to kestegs.
To me, Prestige's actions on Day One and Day Two look like standard mafia behaviour. Tentative to post, but quick to respond when a safe topic is presented or someone interacts with him directly. Typical "don't want to make waves" type of behaviour. Feels safer approaching conversation with his scum buddies (more on the plurality in a second), doesn't interact with those not on his team (I.E., town) unless they approach him first.
Then there is this post:
Scenario one: Both scum.
Scenario two: Zarni scum, Drixx town.
Scenario three: Zarni town, Drixx scum.
Where is scenario four, where both are town? This screams to me like mafia member trying to set up a lynch train on two people he knows will both flip town.
His move of day one vote helps prevent the lynching of his partner, but still allows him to keep a vote on a mafia partner should he later be flipped and revealed scum. His day two vote stays on Zarniwoop the entire day, even though he fingers kestegs and prestige as his two highest scum reads. These are the actions of someone who, when his partners flip, can reach back and say "Hey, I thought he was scum this entire time!", but doesn't want to actively help in their demise.
I'm of the opinion that D2DC and kestegs are partners amd Prestige was on their team.
Vote: DiabloTwoinDC
I could also be persuaded to move my vote to kestegs.
What I find most interesting is that everyone that has posted since Drixx's HUGE reveal (except me) has completely ignored (or tried to avoid) his ability claim and result.
They have also ignored my follow up and suggestion. Its a pretty ugly look.
CG you are way onto my watch list now.
They have also ignored my follow up and suggestion. Its a pretty ugly look.
CG you are way onto my watch list now.
Damnit. Got busy at work, and now I lost my quotes 'cause I'm on another computer.
What I remember: At first I was doubting Diablo, since he seemed weird. But then I got good vibes again, based on him being insistent about his questioning and him having paranoid thoughts about Drixx and someone else possibly being mafia/mafia together.
And I think that was as of page 6. So gonna continue reading from there.
What I remember: At first I was doubting Diablo, since he seemed weird. But then I got good vibes again, based on him being insistent about his questioning and him having paranoid thoughts about Drixx and someone else possibly being mafia/mafia together.
And I think that was as of page 6. So gonna continue reading from there.
Slightly townie'ish paranoia to have.
Hmm. Well, this clears Zarniwoop at least. Either Drixx is town and telling the truth, or he is mafia making a weird play, but I think he wouldn't do that with Zarni as his mafia partner.
While I didn't feel that good about Drixx before this, I... Just sort of believe this.
So Drixx and Zarni town. Me town. That's 3 towns already.
So for one, I mostly like zemaj's reads here.
But more importantly, I don't think he sets this trap as a mafia. That's an advanced play to pull here. Has anyone seen zemaj do anything remotely similar as scum before?
So that means we can add zemaj as 4th town*
*Since some communities will have strong reactions to such a statement, I am of course not locking this in or saying it's 100%, but it's the assumption I'm working with for now at least, call it 85% sure
What have you claimed, Zarni? And what has zemaj claimed?
What I find strange is that YOU haven't reacted to it. And that more people in general haven't reacted to it.
You are maybe my biggest scum read atm.
And again I find you to be focusing on weird stuff. Like, Prestige voted me... So why don't you even comment on that whatsoever?
Agree 100%.
So I mentioned before I sort of had Diablo as a town lean. But it was based on quotes that I can't even remember that clearly anymore, so put him back to neutral.
Townies:
Mr_Thingyman
Zarniwoop
Drixx
zemaj
Neutral:
DiabloTwoinDC
kestegs
Leopold Stotch
Scum:
Caluin Graye
Is it very likely that there are third party roles in this game? I'm not used to them being in games this small. But it seems you're all talking like it's quite likely? That will make this game much more difficult, sigh :/
Mr_Thingyman
Zarniwoop
Drixx
zemaj
Neutral:
DiabloTwoinDC
kestegs
Leopold Stotch
Scum:
Caluin Graye
Is it very likely that there are third party roles in this game? I'm not used to them being in games this small. But it seems you're all talking like it's quite likely? That will make this game much more difficult, sigh :/
Vote: Caluin Graye
So to summarize, I suspect CG based on him not focusing on what I find to be pertinent matters. And more importantly, compared to other players, he just hasn't had any impact or any "I'm trying hard to solve the game" vibes in his posts. It's what players on my site would call a tone read. He appears to just be posting to seem like a townie.
So to summarize, I suspect CG based on him not focusing on what I find to be pertinent matters. And more importantly, compared to other players, he just hasn't had any impact or any "I'm trying hard to solve the game" vibes in his posts. It's what players on my site would call a tone read. He appears to just be posting to seem like a townie.
I'll check in later to see how the votes are looking.
It seems kestegs might be the second most or even the number one most suspected person in the game, and if you guys REALLY want to go for him first, I'll look at it more carefully later, but... My gut isn't sure on him.
It seems kestegs might be the second most or even the number one most suspected person in the game, and if you guys REALLY want to go for him first, I'll look at it more carefully later, but... My gut isn't sure on him.
