Remove ads & support the site - Get PurePremium

The Weather Outside Is Frightful! Die Hard Christmas Mafia Game - Day 4 (Game over - Scum Win)

Pyrotechnician said:
- I would not be confident that everyone else does not have a name (like honestly, there at least has to be THE John McClane). Even though the flips were Agent Johnson 1 and 2, thats still technically a name.
Click to expand...
I was/am pretty certain there is at least Mr McClane and a Hans. Beyond that, I have no idea how many PRs/character names are out there. My assumption was that anybody with a VT was nameless, and would just be revealed as an "Agent Johnson 1, 2, 3" etc.
 
@Pyrotechnician @Noodle
M-vanillizer.png
 
I can't remember who else was in that game.. But, iirc Noodle was basically confirmed town (outed cop?), I was an outed doc, and Pyro was our scum. Yea, I think Noodle was a cop. He had already investigated me as town, and I just claimed in the thread that I was gonna protect Noodle that night so he could do his investigation.

I fully expected to be NKd that night. But, our cop would survive and ID our last town/scum. Then town could vote Pyro out for the win (there was still 1 other townie alive at that point). Instead, what happened was Pyro "vanillaised" me (nullifying my doc save) AND NKd Noodle in the same night. I woke up to a PM saying "you've been vanillaised", and I was alive and Noodle dead. I'm just like WTF?!?

In game, I'm scrambling to explain what happened. And, although we figured out exactly what happened, nobody believed me because the story was just too crazy. First, (if I was scum) how would I come up with a crazy story like that? Secondly, why would I? I already had a town investigation on me. Although I may face a GF argument the final day, wouldn't that be a much easier sell than my crazy story?
 
:sleep:

We need @Babyhell back to liven up this place!

@everyone, Pyro knows me well enough to know I haven't made this nonsense up. His analysis has been intentionally non-committal because he doesn't want to take me off the chopping block.
 
I hear you D2. In your shoes I may be doing the same. But your vote on pryo seems like you’re voting him because of that previous game, not even this one. You ask for help then vote for him?
Iirc a couple of us have said that Noodle votes only when it is a strong vote. I think one person even almost deferred to his voting as their decision. If noodle and him are tag teaming this, they’ve put a lot on the line voting for you saying vote them next if they’re wrong.

This game isn’t over yet. With fewer players it makes it easier to prevent a NK. That gets us closer to the W.
 
I really did forget to give D2DC a role name., yes it's Argyle.

But, I'm not saying anything else alignment wise, role wise, etc, etc.
 
Gorny said:
I really did forget to give D2DC a role name., yes it's Argyle.

But, I'm not saying anything else alignment wise, role wise, etc, etc.
Click to expand...
Huh.

@Noodle, any comment?

I feel like the guy in Fifth Element (my personal Bruce Willis movie) who is about to launch the nukes and goes 'I have a doubt'....
 
Vote: Pyrotechnician

I think he's scum. Will have to read up yesterday to confirm. I could also vote for Noodle or Leo, but those are both more of the "lynch a lurker" guesses.
 
coju said:
I hear you D2. In your shoes I may be doing the same. But your vote on pryo seems like you’re voting him because of that previous game, not even this one. You ask for help then vote for him?
Click to expand...
Coju, I really expected him to see through the muck of my story. Pyro is very good at level-headed/big picture analysis.

He seemed to be reaching for specific things that he could point to as if to say, "I'm still undecided". When he is very good at looking at all the evidence and making a good judgement. It feels like he was intentionally waffling, when I believe he knew the truth.

Either he didn't want to stick his neck out on the line with his assessment, or (more likely) he's scum and didn't want to help clear the guy that was on the chopping block.
 
That's a pretty big T confirm! I cannot see Argyle being anything but town. I still don't know about your role, it seems very, odd.
@Gorny Is the name one that was there from the beginning?
 
Unvote: Noodle

I’m still more on the D2DC vote for today.
Does sir rugs a lot have anything to say?
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
PurePremium
Top Bottom
Back