Fallout 4 Mafia Game Thread

Could someone please tell me how many roles are usually given to town with 10 players? What are the usual roles?

Do you guys ever do role call here? If so, when do you guys do it?

Just so you know if I were really a mafia, I could have just asked my mafia partner.

Setup speculating! Classic scum move!
 
So, what's your role then?

Thank you for your interest, but I was really hoping Zarni would respond. Do you really really want to know? Like Really Really though?

Holy scum guacamole.

May as well add some sour cream to that.

I never said I protected myself. The role you described is close to what I described, except with the caveat that I do not die when my target is attacked. I do admit that the role is slightly non-standard, but bodygaurds and doctors are quite common roles.

As for if it's a fake claim or not, I guess you'll find out in a few hours, won't you?

I guess we will, won't we.

Hopefully he flips Mafia. To me, it looks like they are in damage control mode. Pyro attacking other players, trying to start another train. Now, CG trying to deflect attention to Noodle and Zarni.

CG may flip mafia if he does, great, we can pretty much say everything hes said is a lie, if he flips town, completely different story now isn't it? Either way, my connection to him is nil. You are not looking at the whole picture.
 
Could someone please tell me how many roles are usually given to town with 10 players? What are the usual roles?

Do you guys ever do role call here? If so, when do you guys do it?

Just so you know if I were really a mafia, I could have just asked my mafia partner.

Setup speculating! Classic scum move!

This is the most WIFOM post in the game so far.

Unvote: Zarniwoop
Vote: wanjai


Just for the WIFOM of it all, since it doesn't matter.

That being said, a mass role claim tomorrow would not be a miss dependent on the flip and tonight's activity.
 
As far as I can remember she's only jumped on board trains already being pushed, but does not actually do any real scum hunting of her own.

I'm the second person who voted Prestige and you. I suspected you since yesterday.

You are actually the person who jumped on the train vote with Prestige yesterday, not me.
 
Unvote: Zarniwoop
Vote: wanjai


Just for the WIFOM of it all, since it doesn't matter.

That being said, a mass role claim tomorrow would not be a miss dependent on the flip and tonight's activity.

Would you please kindly at least answer my question?I'm really curious.
 
Thank you for your interest, but I was really hoping Zarni would respond. Do you really really want to know? Like Really Really though?

Like really really. Pretty please, with cherries on top. ;)

Pyro, Noammr, D2DC, and franklin all come across as town at this point in time.

Prediction: (assuming CG flips Mafia) NK will be among these 4 (really 3). Today Pyro and CG seem to be making a coordinated effort to put some heat on Zarni, Noodle, and Wanjai. They obviously won't want to NK one of them, since they're hoping to get a town lynch tomorrow. So, NK will be either D2DC, Noammr, and Franklin.
 
Would you please kindly at least answer my question?I'm really curious.

Yes, we do mass role claim in these games, the timing varies on the number of players in the game, and the progression of the game itself. Some players (i.e. Noodle) refuse to role claim regardless if a mass role claim is called for. In the current game, scum are provided with fake claims so it may be less helpful than normal although tomorrow (in my mind) would be the ideal time.
 
Like really really. Pretty please, with cherries on top.

Why do you need to know his role so badly?

Regretting ever considering you town.



Prediction: (assuming CG flips Mafia) NK will be among these 4 (really 3). Today Pyro and CG seem to be making a coordinated effort to put some heat on Zarni, Noodle, and Wanjai. They obviously won't want to NK one of them, since they're hoping to get a town lynch tomorrow. So, NK will be either D2DC, Noammr, and Franklin.

The mafia will never do what you want them to do, no matter how much you speculate.

That aside, you're going on record saying that wanjai, Zarniwoop, and Pyro are your top three scum? Funny how that matches well with my reads, excepting one person that is.

If you think you might be a target tonight, why aren't you posting your player reads so the town has them in case of your demise?
 
Pyro, you couldn't have have dug your own hole any better.

I'll just bet you want a mass role claim.
 
Why do you need to know his role so badly?

Not like I need it so badly, but Pyro was the one volunteering to start role claims, and then never backed it up.

You want to full role claim right now? I'll even go first. I'm pretty sure you'll change your mind.


That aside, you're going on record saying that wanjai, Zarniwoop, and Pyro are your top three scum? Funny how that matches well with my reads, excepting one person that is.

That is not what I said at all. You're twisting what was said to try to push your agenda. I'm saying that YOU and PYRO are pushing Wanjai, Zarni, and Noodle as scummy. Because you're trying to avoid a lynch on Pyro tomorrow.
 
Like really really. Pretty please, with cherries on top. ;)



Prediction: (assuming CG flips Mafia) NK will be among these 4 (really 3). Today Pyro and CG seem to be making a coordinated effort to put some heat on Zarni, Noodle, and Wanjai. They obviously won't want to NK one of them, since they're hoping to get a town lynch tomorrow. So, NK will be either D2DC, Noammr, and Franklin.

Pyro, you couldn't have have dug your own hole any better.

I'll just bet you want a mass role claim.

You know what? You want it? You got it. But since you are topping the charts in terms of scumminess (along with a number of others), I'm not giving you the full deal since I'm pretty sure you won't reciprocate. I'm the sole survivor, since you are as proficient as I am at using wiki I'm sure you can figure out what that means pretty fast. Do I have an ability? Maybe, maybe not, but it doesn't benefit the town at this point in time to know if I have one or what that ability is, and would only help the scum to know. Do with that information what you will, but I'm pretty confident that no one else is going to step forward and claim the role of the protagonist, even with the scum being provided fake claims.

Why did I wait so long to claim? I didn't have anything additional that claiming would add at this time, and since the mafia have day talk, if CG comes up as scum, I wanted to give him as little time as possible to talk with his cohort.
 
If you think you might be a target tonight, why aren't you posting your player reads so the town has them in case of your demise?

Be glad to. I've quoted/agreed with other player reads along the way, but here is my full list:

D2DC and Zarni - helpful townies. There is the possibility that Zarni is just playing the part. But, I have several others that I'm more suspicious of before considering that.

Franklin, Noammr, Wanjai - leaning town. I may have been catching some flak in the beginning as a consequence of the Borderlands game, but Franklin and Noammr look to be scum hunting. Wanjai is on her first SPF Mafia game, and is getting accused of being scummy for the same things I did my first couple games.

Pyro and Noodle - Leaning Scum. Noodle not so much anything he's done. Looks like he's actually posting more than usual. But, the fact that roles were hand picked makes me automatically suspicious. Was on the fence about Pyro, but after today, leaning heavy mafia.
 
If you're the "Sole Survivor" then I'm assuming your Mafia role is "survivor" and wincon is to just survive until one faction or the other achieves their wincon. So, why wouldn't we want to lynch you ASAP? The longer you're around, you could swing the game one way or the other..
 
If you're the "Sole Survivor" then I'm assuming your Mafia role is "survivor" and wincon is to just survive until one faction or the other achieves their wincon. So, why wouldn't we want to lynch you ASAP? The longer you're around, you could swing the game one way or the other..

Wow...I have not been this frustrated with a mafia game since the game with all the boxes...

Sole Survivor as in the main playable character, i.e. another settlement is in need of my help.
 
Wow...I have not been this frustrated with a mafia game since the game with all the boxes...

Lol. Okay. "Sole Survivor" with an unrevealed PR not "survivor". I'm reading both wikis right now.
 
Sole Survivor as in the main playable character, i.e. another settlement is in need of my help.

Are you saying that you are one of the townie?
At this point, You are still the most suspicious to me whether CG flips scum or not. You either protect CG because he is your scum partner, or it he flips town (which you know that he would), then you can act like "see, I told you so, he is town" to gain trust from townies.

To me, CG's role claim seems like a fake claim. I could be wrong but we will see in a few hours.
 
Lol. Okay. "Sole Survivor" with an unrevealed PR not "survivor". I'm reading both wikis right now.

Yes, sorry if that was unclear....

Are you saying that you are one of the townie?

Yes, I am "one of the townie", for those unfamiliar with fallout like myself, there is a main playable character in fallout 4, the main playable character is the "sole survivor", as in he is the only one that comes out of Vault 111 (refer back to the videos that silver posted in the beginning of the game thread). You play as this character throughout the entire game. This is the character I am claiming to be. I know theme and flavor are supposed to be just additional to the game, but its pretty straightforward in this case.

At this point, You are still the most suspicious to me whether CG flips scum or not. You either protect CG because he is your scum partner, or it he flips town (which you know that he would), then you can act like "see, I told you so, he is town" to gain trust from townies.

To me, CG's role claim seems like a fake claim. I could be wrong but we will see in a few hours.

So either I'm scum or I'm scum? Seems pretty unfair to me. How about you? What happens if he flips town? Do you get off scott free because you can just say "huh, surprising, totally thought he was scum". Everyone needs to be looked at, there is a very narrow focus happening right now that only helps the scum.

Yes, his claim could be fake, I'm not doubting that, but I'm saying that either way I am not connected to him.
 
DAY 1:
I am saddened that I cannot vendetta vote for Ankeli.

I am saddened that I cannot secondary-vendetta vote for Bad Ash.

Oh, I can tertiary vendetta vote for Pyro!

Vote: Pyrotechnician


Hmm, I may have too many vendettas.

Final End of Day Vote Count and Announcement:

Noammr: 2 (Wanjai, Thefranklin)
Caluin Graye: 1 (D2DC)
Zarniwoop: 1 (Noodle)
Thefranklin: 1 (Noammr)
Zemaj: 1 (Prestige 7)
Noodle: 2 (Zarniwoop, Pyrotechnician)
PyroTechnician: 2 (Caluin Graye, Zemaj)

I am Preston Garvey. Bodyguard, but I don't die if my target is shot, so I guess it's just a flavoured form of Doctor.

N1: Protected Pyro.

D1 you only made 3 posts. And 1/3 was just to claim an item. Another one, to vote Pyro. And then N1 you say that you decided to protect Pyro? Seems a bit strange to me..
 
Franklin, Noammr, Wanjai - leaning town. I may have been catching some flak in the beginning as a consequence of the Borderlands game, but Franklin and Noammr look to be scum hunting. Wanjai is on her first SPF Mafia game, and is getting accused of being scummy for the same things I did my first couple games.

First game or not, she's getting accused of being scum because she's playing like how a scum would.
 
PurePremium