I'm purposefully not looking into past games, I don't want to know what this rivalry was between Pyro and DC. It should have nothing to do with this game.
Zemaj came late, and appeared to not offer anything, even jokingly. I could vote for Zemaj with clear concious.
I don't like how Noodle said he was suspicious of anyone casting a vote thus far, even though at the time, I personally felt both votes were jokes. (because Noodle is not bread) Maybe Pyro's vote was not a joke, but just taking any grounds at all to justify a blind vote. I could easily vote for Noodle because of his seeming disconnect from who had voted, although it might just be my perception.
That leaves Tears, Huckit, and Leopold. Tears at least talked about poker strategy. Leopold wants to wait until D2 to start playing. Huckit, I dunno, don't see much there.
Top choices for me, in no order, are Leopold, Noodle, or Zemaj.
If my choice is to fall in line, or potentially sew chaos, I'll fall in line, for now.
Vote: Noodle