Gorny's Too Much Scum Mafia Game *** Day 6 *** (Game over Town Win)
- Thread starter Gorny
- Start date
You must be geting rusty zemaj, if I feel like I'm in a position to make the thinly veiled taunts then I must have a reason right, so therefore you should already have your answer in regards my interaction with Tears.
Before I get all serious and clarify some things, because I think everyone has posted at least something at this point...
Ha! I missed the funny joke, I had to go back and find it (could use a little work though
) Probably to put easy heat on me because of our past grudge match and the interaction I had with D2DC on day.
I got on right in time between the two and I was so so tempted to post just to post and interrupt you.
If we lynch Noodle, and he is the serial killer, that's great news. With 1 mafioso reportedly down, this is a good position to be in.
If we lynch Noodle, and he is NOT the serial killer, then you would certainly have a tough situation to explain yourself out of...
Also, I wonder why D2DC first? Roll of the dice? Pyro-venge?
Ha! I missed the funny joke, I had to go back and find it (could use a little work though
) Probably to put easy heat on me because of our past grudge match and the interaction I had with D2DC on day.Woot! No posts between!
I got on right in time between the two and I was so so tempted to post just to post and interrupt you.
Vote count 2.0:
Noodle: 4 (Tears85, zemaj, Logoutzero, huckit
Not voting: Noodle, Pryo, Leo,
For a minute there, I wasn't sure on counting Huckit's vote because the "Vote" part of his Vote: Noodle did not look bolded, but on closer look it was, so it counts.
Noodle is at 4 votes and will be lynched at the end of the day if he is still at 4, another vote on Noodle will lock.
Noodle: 4 (Tears85, zemaj, Logoutzero, huckit
Not voting: Noodle, Pryo, Leo,
For a minute there, I wasn't sure on counting Huckit's vote because the "Vote" part of his Vote: Noodle did not look bolded, but on closer look it was, so it counts.
Noodle is at 4 votes and will be lynched at the end of the day if he is still at 4, another vote on Noodle will lock.
I'm willing to lock the vote, however, I would like to hear from noodle anyway
Noodle, any last replies?
Noodle, any last replies?
So, this is me on record confirming that Tears and I are neighbors, and we are not just standard neighbors, we are confirmed town with each other. If I were to describe what it would be called using standard mafia roles its more like masons. We can talk freely with eachother during the course of the game. If I had to take a guess as to why we are neighbors its probably because this is Tears' first game so its probably to help him get up to speed.
I had no knowledge of his claim to be the FBI agent, it wasn't brought up in our discussion but if I had to take a guess there is probably a reason why he didn't bring it up (whether that be personal or mod choice or what have you).
That being said just because I didn't know he was the FBI agent still doesn't give me any reason not to trust his claim. I know he is town, and I know he is a new player, so he was probably excited to reveal his results right away.
Is there a possibility that he could be insane as some of you have mentioned? Yes, possibly, but I highly doubt it:
1. The game rules and setup specifically say there is an FBI agent and he can only find the serial killer.
2. Making that role insane doesn't fit with the typical setup, not saying I wouldn't put it past Gorny to do this because he does things like this, but I would find it hard to change a role that will only find one specific person into an insane role on top of it. If he could find any of the scum then yeah I could see it *possibly* being insane.
For the crazy conspiracy theory people out there who are saying Tears and I are possibly colluding instead, that's a stretch. We've already had one mafia goon turn up dead, and if you think about the setup that would have to mean that both Tears and I are scum as well, and that would make it 3 scum and 1 sk in a game of 8 people. There is also no counter claim to Tears claim of being the FBI agent.
Noodle hasn't shown his face much since Tears claim, so I think its pretty safe to do the following:
Vote: Noodle
I had no knowledge of his claim to be the FBI agent, it wasn't brought up in our discussion but if I had to take a guess there is probably a reason why he didn't bring it up (whether that be personal or mod choice or what have you).
That being said just because I didn't know he was the FBI agent still doesn't give me any reason not to trust his claim. I know he is town, and I know he is a new player, so he was probably excited to reveal his results right away.
Is there a possibility that he could be insane as some of you have mentioned? Yes, possibly, but I highly doubt it:
1. The game rules and setup specifically say there is an FBI agent and he can only find the serial killer.
2. Making that role insane doesn't fit with the typical setup, not saying I wouldn't put it past Gorny to do this because he does things like this, but I would find it hard to change a role that will only find one specific person into an insane role on top of it. If he could find any of the scum then yeah I could see it *possibly* being insane.
For the crazy conspiracy theory people out there who are saying Tears and I are possibly colluding instead, that's a stretch. We've already had one mafia goon turn up dead, and if you think about the setup that would have to mean that both Tears and I are scum as well, and that would make it 3 scum and 1 sk in a game of 8 people. There is also no counter claim to Tears claim of being the FBI agent.
Noodle hasn't shown his face much since Tears claim, so I think its pretty safe to do the following:
Vote: Noodle
My reasoning for waiting as long as I did to confirm Tears as my neighbor is pretty much what I said to Zemaj. I wanted to see how each of you would respond to his claim without me automatically backing up his claim. If I confirmed it right away there would have been almost no discussion for the entire day. But now, instead, we have another full day of posts to look at while we are trying to find our last mafia. Since the setup pretty much spells out that the mafia have no night kill, and it looks like we will be taking out our serial killer now, it will probably be pretty hard to pick out the last mafia without some digging (Unless for some reason there are no mechanics that can stop the town from winning at this point and the game is called, but lets not get ahead of ourselves knowing how Gorny mods his games)
I'm typing on phone so it's a little hard to reply in the way that I want to...
Pyro, you say you have no knowledge that Tears was going to claim FBI, however, how is it that you didn't know he was going to claim his role.? I guess what I'm trying to say is him not telling you hey I'm going to claim my roll tomorrow is a little fishy to me. He had to have said something.
I agree with you about the scum numbers (3 mafia, 1 sk) but the title of the game IS to much scum so I am a little inclined to believe it...
Pyro, you say you have no knowledge that Tears was going to claim FBI, however, how is it that you didn't know he was going to claim his role.? I guess what I'm trying to say is him not telling you hey I'm going to claim my roll tomorrow is a little fishy to me. He had to have said something.
I agree with you about the scum numbers (3 mafia, 1 sk) but the title of the game IS to much scum so I am a little inclined to believe it...
@Pyro and everybody: I´m not allowed to write about me being the FBI agent in Pyro + ME neighbore chat. I´ve stated that when I claimed to be FBI Agent! Furthermore I just wanted to reveal my knowledge before it would have been odd in any way. Ofc I didn´t think about anything but: I got the SK!
Because I wanted to hear what Noodle has to say before locking in someone who has yet to defend himself.
OK! Yet Pyro didn´t have knwoledge that I will claim being FBI...I wrote that I most likely will claim we are neoighbores.....than claimed everything before he replied! But claiming everything achieved the goal of getting Noodle = to me confirmed SK lynched!
He gave me about a whole 5 minutes to respond before he posted his claim in the game thread. So, if you want to say its fishy, thats fine. But its not like I had a lot of time to tell him not to. You know I usually play with known information a little closer to the vest to see if I can draw some other people out before going straight up claim mode.
Ok, so, time to move into our next lynch? Since we have a lock on Noodle can we lynch again or do we have to wait for tomorrow? Anyone else get a scum read on Leopold and Zemaj’s slow response to all this? I assume they benefit by having the SK around for a bit to thin out the village, or am I reading that wrong?
I see your eagerness here to move on and scum hunt. Possible over-eager. Like trying to hide in plain sight.
Not even remotely interested in waiting for Noodle's flip? Seems an awful lot like scum to me.
I do know. But I also feel that if y'all were mafia, Tears would be scared because it's his first game and he's like, "Pyro, I literally don't know what to do." And you and DC gave him a cover. DC got killed so now it's just y'all two which makes it a little more convenient.
I know I've been scummy for some of y'all but I assure you there will be nothing to gain from my kill except hurt the town.
