Fallout 4 Mafia Game Thread

I dunno what his wincon was, but he wasn't scum. And, Marty McFly is the good guy.. unless I'm missing something?

You didn't miss it, but if you don't know his wincon, you sure as hell can't count on his vote to be on scum when it counts. So to a town perspective, he is scum. And t a scum perspective, he is town.

Which is why the two locking votes are red flags. It puts a pretty big target on CG, and the fact Zemaj is gone makes the target even bigger.
 
If I ask people to contribute any information gained during night actions, and you gripe..

Correct, because that is a topic traditionally brought up by mafia.

Again, ask for info from night actions, no response. Specifically about Stealth Boy? No response. There MUST be SOMETHING to say. I even shared the fact that NO INFO was given with the Thermo Goggles, which Zarni corroborated. ESPECIALLY in clear weather, people got out last night, but aren't coming forward with info.

There is nothing to say. You yourself state that you have NO INFO about the Thermo Goggles. What makes you think that the Stealth Boys are any different?

I'm going back, reading Jamez posts, now that we can trust what he said. And you were his #1 scum smelling..

You're going to trust a neutral who had luke warm reads on every single player. Super.

You were the last player to vote Prestige (after there were already 6 votes). Curious why you vote for Zarni? He is one of my more town reads. Granted Prestige didn't flip Mafia. But, maybe you were hoping to get a lynch on someone other than a low-activity, neutral player..

Check the time stamps on those votes and you'll realize why this statement is bad. Also, Prestige flipped not-town. You're upset because the town lynched someone not-town.

Does nobody else find that frustrating?

I agree. You are posting more than some players, but not all that much. You sure are around to pounce on all the useful items though.

There's that hypocrisy again! I'd like to remind everyone that D2DC tried to snag that second Stealth Boy right as I did, but conveniently does not bring that up.

I agree with this also. Your entire player by player analysis seemed intended to supply as little info as possible, mostly "null reads".

Do you realize that Pyro was talking about zemaj in this post, not me? Also, sorry I haven't been able to deliver all of the scum to everyone by day 2, I'll try harder. /sarcasm
 
What makes you think that the Stealth Boys are any different?

We have several people saying that there was no info provided on the goggles. You're the only player that has had Stealth Boy, now in good weather conditions. And, you still haven't provided any info about them.

I DID make a grab for them. I have a feeling they are useful in defense as well as offense. How you gonna get NK if nobody can see you? And, if I did get them, I would happily provide whatever info I get about them. Even if it's just a "no info".

I'm pretty sure you were able to use them at least one of the nights. Did it say you will be immune to tracking? Did it confirm that someone with thermal goggles could track? You're not coming forward with anything.
 
You didn't miss it, but if you don't know his wincon, you sure as hell can't count on his vote to be on scum when it counts. So to a town perspective, he is scum. And t a scum perspective, he is town.

Which is why the two locking votes are red flags. It puts a pretty big target on CG, and the fact Zemaj is gone makes the target even bigger.

You too? I expected better of you, frankie. This reeks of opportunistic train jumping.
 
You're missing that he was not town.

NOT. TOWN.

Why would you ever trust someone that has a different win condition than you?

Maybe I just don't have experience playing with neutrals. The only roles I know about from MS are SK and Survivor. And, Marty McFly doesn't sound like an SK..

I was kind of on the fence about losing two neutrals. But, if you're telling me thats good for the town, even better.
 
D2DC is the center of attention today what with the early information claim and the apparent post restriction. Either helpful townie or scum-in-plain-sight. I feel like he's being earnest though, so leaning town.

wanjai seems concerned about neutrals already, but not much scum hunting. Is awfully concerned about Stealth Boys, but not the other items. New player syndrome? Maybe, but I suspect she's read enough games over D2DC's shoulder she might know better. Slight mafia read.

Zarniwoop seems intent upon playing helpful townie. I'm happy with my vote on him for the moment.

Noodle's vote on D2DC for his post restriction seems opportunistic. I can't really fault him for the annoyance factor, but I'm not willing to lynch D2DC just because he's restricted. For the other things? Sure, yeah.

zemaj and Mr. Berland (Prestige) appear to be coasting so far.

Pyro is playing close to his chest, which is pretty standard for him. See my above reaction to Franklin for how I feel about that.

franklin is being franklin as usual. I like what's he's doing so far.

I missed someone. That probably means something right there.

Do you realize that Pyro was talking about zemaj in this post, not me?

My bad on that one. I did get the two mixed up as well. Partly because they were both mostly a list of "no reads"

Interesting too that you even say I sound like a helpful townie. But, now that I'm coming at you, I'm not so trustworthy?
 
I'm pretty sure you were able to use them at least one of the nights.


Whoa, that's news. I threw a vote out on someone right away to see what would happen knowing that CG would be an easy train to start. Do you have any backing for the above statement, or are you just being opportunistic and letting stuff fly?
 
PurePremium